A Diamond’s Eye View of the World

a multi-faceted look at the middle east, and the middle west

marketing misfires

Posted by adiamondinsunlight on August 8, 2008

Rami of +961 wrote a short post earlier this week on the incongruity of seeing Lebanon-specific ads while reading Haaretz online. As a Lebanese citizen, it must be odd to see ads for “Jobs in Lebanon” (not to mention “Single Lebanese Girls”) while reading an Israeli paper – although I would argue that allowing Israelis and Arab state citizens to read one another’s press has been one of the great regional benefits that the Internet has provided.

Until recently, the Daily Star‘s online ads were similarly incongruous: any article that mentioned Israel would be accompanied by ads to visit Israel or buy Israeli goods, which was a bit jarring when the article was about cluster bombs or new settlements. Someone must have noticed however (maybe the editors, but more likely Google, since I bet those ads didn’t get many click-throughs!), since more recently the ads have stuck to safer topics like “Sexy Lebanese Girls” (its a theme with universal appeal, I guess) and “Fly to Lebanon cheap”.

I understand that these crossovers happen because online ads target customers through keywords and IP addresses, but I was still unprepared for the dramatic shift that took place in the ads I saw on Facebook. One day, I was in Lebanon, seeing ads for a “regime” that promised a 5-10 kg loss and ads for March 14 and other political organizations.

The next day I was in Brooklyn, where suddenly I was being asked to expand my wardrobe by visiting israelmilitary.com, an Israeli army surplus store selling everything from t-shirts to dog tags:

I do like shopping online, but this won’t be my new go-to site. Nor will I be spending much time on Jobshuk.com, a site that aims to “improve the financial situation of Israeli residents” by connecting Israelis in need of jobs with “Zionists worldwide”. (Shuk is the Hebrew word for “market” – and yes, its a close cousin of “souk”, the Arabic word.)

Why am I not a fan of Job Shuk? Because when it states that: “The alarming numbers of poverty, hunger, and unemployment in Israel are incongruous with the advanced, democratic, and technically advanced society which we are developing,” it isn’t referring to poverty, hunger, or unemployment among Palestinians.

Don’t get me wrong – I love many things about New York internet, not least its speed. But when it comes to advertising, I would be happy to have my Beirut IP back. Especially since half the time it put me in Lithuania.


3 Responses to “marketing misfires”

  1. Not to get into a political dispute, but it’s hard to open our hearts to a people whose public message is the destruction of our population and land. When the “Palestinians” destroy the infrastructure given to them, such as in the disengagement in Gaza, or take the job opportunities given to them to run Israelis over with bulldozers, it’s hard to forgive and forget.

    Political views aside, JobShuk is a business model aimed for a niche market, and unapologetically does not include “Palestinians” in that market, just as The National Organization for Women is not designed for men.

  2. Kheireddine said

    Don’t you ever ask yourselves, Zvi, why the Palestinians hate you? If one second, you put yourselves in their shoes and you think about the injustice they suffered since 1948. Modern Israel is a historical and geopolitic aberration that was created by force in a sea of Arabs and Moslems, so expect them to hate you for ever and to overrun you one day.

  3. […] come to my work email, the various financial scam emails that find me at home, and (of course) the pro-Israel ads that try to lure me on […]

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: